[LLVMdev] ATTENTION: SymbolTable Change!!

Tue May 25 07:21:17 PDT 2004

LLVMers,

On the way to resolving bug 122, I am committing my SymbolTable rewrite.
If you are working on anything that uses the SymbolTable, I suggest you
read the documentation in include/llvm/SymbolTable.h.

The changes I've committed reduce the use of Type::TypeTy. This static
member will go away in the future, so please do not propagate new code
that uses it. There is no reason to use it in order to access the "type
plane" in the new SymbolTable. There are some corner cases where its
still needed elsewhere, however.

Here's a quickie summary of how the new SymbolTable interface affects
its users:

1. The data structures are embedded so if you were thinking of using
    any std::map functionality, its gone.

2. Some of the generic std::map functionality has been added to
   SymbolTable to make it compatible (e.g. empty() ).

3. The iterator names and concepts have changed significantly. In the
   future, please use the following conventions:

(a) To iterate over the all type planes use plane_begin() and
     plane_end(). These are semantically equivalent to the begin() and
     end() methods inherited from std::map on the old SymbolTable. For 
     iterating over planes, please use an iterator named PI.

(b) To iterate over the type type plane (the plane of Type::TypeTy),
     please use type_begin() and type_end(). Previously, users of the
     SymbolTable would use ST.find(Type::TypeTy) to access the type
     type plane. This is now semantically incorrect and will always
     return std::map.end()! Use type_begin() and type_end() instead.
     These will get you an iterator over the name/Type pairs in the
     type type plane. For iteration over types, please use an iterator
     named TI.

(c) To iterate over the values in one type plane (except for the
     plane of types), use value_begin(Type*) and value_end(Type*). 
     These methods will get you an iterator over the name/Value
     pairs in the single type plane given by the arguments. For 
     iterating over values, please use an iterator named VI.

4. Some functionality (like "strip") has been moved into the 
     SymbolTable. This means that the SymbolStripping pass is now 
     a single call to the SymbolTable::strip() method.

These changes pass all feature tests. Some of the regression tests fail
and I'm not sure if its due to (a) my changes, (b) my old cfrontend, or
(c) someone else's changes. I suspect its more of (b) and (c) but I will
look into this in more detail later this week.

Next steps on bug 122 (each a separate commit):
* Completely rid ourselves of Type::TypeTy. This involves a rewrite of
  the SlotCalculator which will be divided up between Bytecode writer
  and ASM writer.
* Make Type not inherit from Value and fix the resulting fall out.
* Get rid of ConstantPointerRef.

If you have *any* questions about this, please email me.

Thanks,

Reid.

Here's the Feature/Regression test results:

--- STATISTICS
---------------------------------------------------------------

     902        tests total
     874 ( 97%) tests as expected
      27 (  3%) tests unexpected FAIL
       1 (  0%) tests unexpected PASS

--- TESTS WITH UNEXPECTED OUTCOMES
-------------------------------------------

  Regression.Assembler.ConstantExprFold         : FAIL    , expected
PASS
    Script:
/proj/work/llvm/build/test/tmp/trConstantExprFold.llx/testscript.ConstantExprFold.llx
    Output:
/proj/work/llvm/build/test/tmp/trConstantExprFold.llx/testscript.ConstantExprFold.llx.out

  Regression.C++Frontend.2004-01-11-DynamicInitializedConstant: FAIL   
, expected PASS
    Script:
/proj/work/llvm/build/test/tmp/tr2004-01-11-DynamicInitializedConstant.cpp.tr/testscript.2004-01-11-DynamicInitializedConstant.cpp.tr
    Output:
/proj/work/llvm/build/test/tmp/tr2004-01-11-DynamicInitializedConstant.cpp.tr/testscript.2004-01-11-DynamicInitializedConstant.cpp.tr.out

  Regression.C++Frontend.2004-03-08-ReinterpretCastCopy: FAIL    ,
expected PASS
    Compiling C++ code failed

  Regression.C++Frontend.2004-03-15-CleanupsAndGotos: FAIL    , expected
PASS
    Compiling C++ code failed

  Regression.CFrontend.2002-07-14-MiscListTests : FAIL    , expected
PASS
    Compiling code failed

  Regression.CFrontend.2003-06-29-MultipleFunctionDefinition: FAIL    ,
expected PASS
    Compiling C code failed

  Regression.CFrontend.2003-12-14-ExternInlineSupport: FAIL    ,
expected PASS
    Script:
/proj/work/llvm/build/test/tmp/tr2003-12-14-ExternInlineSupport.c.tr/testscript.2003-12-14-ExternInlineSupport.c.tr
    Output:
/proj/work/llvm/build/test/tmp/tr2003-12-14-ExternInlineSupport.c.tr/testscript.2003-12-14-ExternInlineSupport.c.tr.out

  Regression.CFrontend.2004-01-08-ExternInlineRedefine: FAIL    ,
expected PASS
    Compiling C code failed

  Regression.CFrontend.2004-02-12-LargeAggregateCopy: FAIL    , expected
PASS
    Script:
/proj/work/llvm/build/test/tmp/tr2004-02-12-LargeAggregateCopy.c.tr/testscript.2004-02-12-LargeAggregateCopy.c.tr
    Output:
/proj/work/llvm/build/test/tmp/tr2004-02-12-LargeAggregateCopy.c.tr/testscript.2004-02-12-LargeAggregateCopy.c.tr.out

  Regression.CFrontend.2004-02-13-BuiltinFrameReturnAddress: FAIL    ,
expected PASS
    Script:
/proj/work/llvm/build/test/tmp/tr2004-02-13-BuiltinFrameReturnAddress.c.tr/testscript.2004-02-13-BuiltinFrameReturnAddress.c.tr
    Output:
/proj/work/llvm/build/test/tmp/tr2004-02-13-BuiltinFrameReturnAddress.c.tr/testscript.2004-02-13-BuiltinFrameReturnAddress.c.tr.out

  Regression.CFrontend.2004-02-13-IllegalVararg : FAIL    , expected
PASS
    Script:
/proj/work/llvm/build/test/tmp/tr2004-02-13-IllegalVararg.c.tr/testscript.2004-02-13-IllegalVararg.c.tr
    Output:
/proj/work/llvm/build/test/tmp/tr2004-02-13-IllegalVararg.c.tr/testscript.2004-02-13-IllegalVararg.c.tr.out

  Regression.CFrontend.2004-02-13-Memset        : FAIL    , expected
PASS
    Script:
/proj/work/llvm/build/test/tmp/tr2004-02-13-Memset.c.tr/testscript.2004-02-13-Memset.c.tr
    Output:
/proj/work/llvm/build/test/tmp/tr2004-02-13-Memset.c.tr/testscript.2004-02-13-Memset.c.tr.out

  Regression.CFrontend.2004-02-14-ZeroInitializer: FAIL    , expected
PASS
    Script:
/proj/work/llvm/build/test/tmp/tr2004-02-14-ZeroInitializer.c.tr/testscript.2004-02-14-ZeroInitializer.c.tr
    Output:
/proj/work/llvm/build/test/tmp/tr2004-02-14-ZeroInitializer.c.tr/testscript.2004-02-14-ZeroInitializer.c.tr.out

  Regression.CFrontend.2004-03-07-ComplexDivEquals: FAIL    , expected
PASS
    Compiling C code failed

  Regression.CFrontend.2004-03-15-SimpleIndirectGoto: FAIL    , expected
PASS
    Compiling C code failed

  Regression.CFrontend.2004-03-16-AsmRegisterCrash: FAIL    , expected
PASS
    Compiling C code failed

  Regression.CFrontend.2004-05-21-IncompleteEnum: FAIL    , expected
PASS
    Compiling C code failed

  Regression.CodeGen.Generic.2004-04-09-SameValueCoalescing: FAIL    ,
expected PASS
    Script:
/proj/work/llvm/build/test/tmp/tr2004-04-09-SameValueCoalescing.llx/testscript.2004-04-09-SameValueCoalescing.llx
    Output:
/proj/work/llvm/build/test/tmp/tr2004-04-09-SameValueCoalescing.llx/testscript.2004-04-09-SameValueCoalescing.llx.out

  Regression.CodeGen.Generic.BasicInstrs        : FAIL    , expected
PASS
    Script:
/proj/work/llvm/build/test/tmp/trBasicInstrs.llx/testscript.BasicInstrs.llx
    Output:
/proj/work/llvm/build/test/tmp/trBasicInstrs.llx/testscript.BasicInstrs.llx.out

  Regression.Linker.2003-01-30-LinkerTypeRename : FAIL    , expected
PASS
    Script:
/proj/work/llvm/build/test/tmp/tr2003-01-30-LinkerTypeRename.ll/testscript.2003-01-30-LinkerTypeRename.ll
    Output:
/proj/work/llvm/build/test/tmp/tr2003-01-30-LinkerTypeRename.ll/testscript.2003-01-30-LinkerTypeRename.ll.out

  Regression.Linker.2003-10-21-ConflictingTypesTolerance: FAIL    ,
expected PASS
    Script:
/proj/work/llvm/build/test/tmp/tr2003-10-21-ConflictingTypesTolerance.ll/testscript.2003-10-21-ConflictingTypesTolerance.ll
    Output:
/proj/work/llvm/build/test/tmp/tr2003-10-21-ConflictingTypesTolerance.ll/testscript.2003-10-21-ConflictingTypesTolerance.ll.out

  Regression.Other.2002-03-11-ExprAssertion     : FAIL    , expected
PASS
    Script:
/proj/work/llvm/build/test/tmp/tr2002-03-11-ExprAssertion.ll/testscript.2002-03-11-ExprAssertion.ll
    Output:
/proj/work/llvm/build/test/tmp/tr2002-03-11-ExprAssertion.ll/testscript.2002-03-11-ExprAssertion.ll.out

  Regression.Other.2002-03-14-ValueToLarge      : FAIL    , expected
PASS
    Script:
/proj/work/llvm/build/test/tmp/tr2002-03-14-ValueToLarge.ll/testscript.2002-03-14-ValueToLarge.ll
    Output:
/proj/work/llvm/build/test/tmp/tr2002-03-14-ValueToLarge.ll/testscript.2002-03-14-ValueToLarge.ll.out

  Regression.Transforms.CorrelatedExprs.nullpointer: XPASS

  Regression.Transforms.InstCombine.load        : FAIL    , expected
PASS
    Script: /proj/work/llvm/build/test/tmp/trload.ll/testscript.load.ll
    Output:
/proj/work/llvm/build/test/tmp/trload.ll/testscript.load.ll.out

  Regression.Transforms.InstCombine.phi         : FAIL    , expected
PASS
    Script: /proj/work/llvm/build/test/tmp/trphi.ll/testscript.phi.ll
    Output:
/proj/work/llvm/build/test/tmp/trphi.ll/testscript.phi.ll.out

  Regression.Transforms.SimplifyCFG.2002-05-05-EmptyBlockMerge: FAIL   
, expected PASS
    Script:
/proj/work/llvm/build/test/tmp/tr2002-05-05-EmptyBlockMerge.ll/testscript.2002-05-05-EmptyBlockMerge.ll
    Output:
/proj/work/llvm/build/test/tmp/tr2002-05-05-EmptyBlockMerge.ll/testscript.2002-05-05-EmptyBlockMerge.ll.out

  Regression.Verifier.2002-04-13-RetTypes       : FAIL    , expected
PASS
    /proj/work/llvm/llvm/test/Regression/Verifier/2002-04-13-RetTypes.ll
assembled

gmake: [qmtest] Error 1 (ignored)

-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: signature.asc
Type: application/pgp-signature
Size: 189 bytes
Desc: This is a digitally signed message part
URL: <http://lists.llvm.org/pipermail/llvm-dev/attachments/20040525/94a7a5a7/attachment.sig>