[clang] [Clang] Add __has_target_builtin macro (PR #126324)
Aaron Ballman via cfe-commits
cfe-commits at lists.llvm.org
Wed Feb 12 11:37:54 PST 2025
================
@@ -96,6 +100,55 @@ the ``<cmath>`` header file to conditionally make a function constexpr whenever
the constant evaluation of the corresponding builtin (for example,
``std::fmax`` calls ``__builtin_fmax``) is supported in Clang.
+``__has_target_builtin``
+------------------------
+
+This function-like macro takes a single identifier argument that is the name of
+a builtin function, a builtin pseudo-function (taking one or more type
+arguments), or a builtin template.
+It evaluates to 1 if the builtin is supported on the current target or 0 if not.
+
+``__has_builtin`` and ``__has_target_builtin`` behave identically for normal C++ compilations.
+
+For heterogeneous compilations that see source code intended for more than one target:
+
+``__has_builtin`` returns true if the builtin is known to the compiler
+(i.e. it's available via one of the targets), but makes no promises whether it's available on the current target.
+The compiler can parse it, but not necessarily generate code for it.
+
+``__has_target_builtin`` returns true if the builtin can actually be generated for the current target.
+
+As a motivating example, let's try to guard a builtin call using ``__has_builtin`` in a heterogeneous compilation,
+such as OpenMP Offloading, with the host being x86-64 and the offloading device being AMDGPU.
+
+.. code-block:: c++
+
+ #if __has_builtin(__builtin_ia32_pause)
+ __builtin_ia32_pause();
+ #else
+ abort();
+ #endif
+
+Compilation of this code results in a compiler error because ``__builtin_ia32_pause`` is known to the compiler because
+it is a builtin supported by the host x86-64 compilation so ``__has_builtin`` returns true. However, code cannot
+be generated for ``__builtin_ia32_pause`` during the offload AMDGPU compilation as it is not supported on that target.
----------------
AaronBallman wrote:
Thank you, this is helping somewhat. But I think a user is still going to ask themselves "why does `__has_builtin` return `true` in this case?". The host and the offload are separate compilations, so logically, it stands to reason that `__has_builtin` would return `true` for the host and `false` for the offload. And because of:
> ``__has_builtin`` and ``__has_target_builtin`` behave identically for normal C++ compilations.
They're going to wonder why they wouldn't just replace all uses of `__has_builtin` with `__has_target_builtin`, which begs the question of why `__has_builtin` isn't just being "fixed".
(I'll be honest, I still don't fully understand the answer to that myself.)
https://github.com/llvm/llvm-project/pull/126324
More information about the cfe-commits
mailing list