[LLVMdev] [cfe-dev] RFC: A Great Renaming of Things (or: Let's Repaint ALL the Bikesheds!)

[Michael Spencer]

On Thu, Nov 22, 2012 at 12:56 AM, Chandler Carruth <chandlerc at google.com> wrote:
> Hello LLVM & Clang hackers!
>
> Based on a discussion with Chris, I would like to propose a Great
> Renaming of Things for the 3.3-era LLVM and Clang codebase.
>
> First and foremost, the two most significant changes I would like to make:
>
> 1) llvm/lib/VMCore/... -> llvm/lib/IR/...

I strongly support this.

>
> I've discussed potential names for the VMCore (or LLVMCore) library
> with lots of folks, and the best idea anyone has was Chris's initial
> suggestion: IR. So I'd like to minimize the bikeshed discussions on
> this one. ;]
>
> There is one interesting question here: should we move
> include/llvm/*.h to include/llvm/IR/*.h to match other libraries?

Yes. Very much so. There should be no headers in include/llvm/.

>
>
> 2) clang/lib/CodeGen/... -> clang/lib/IRGen/...

Agreed

>
> I think this name is so painfully obvious that everyone will be happy
> with this change...
>
> ... because it's the biggest change. It will involve a great deal of
> renaming (CodeGenFunction for example) in order to keep things
> consistent.
>
>
> Are there other names that are poor choices and are lingering in our
> codebases? I'm willing to sign up to do more renames while I'm at
> this, so this is a chance to get someone else to do the heavy lifting.
> =]

I really dislike that all the files and classes in the MC library
start with MC. This is c++, not c :(


- Michael Spencer