[PATCH] D50858: [M680x0] Add ELF and Triple info

Kristina Brooks via Phabricator via llvm-commits llvm-commits at lists.llvm.org
Sun Sep 16 10:57:37 PDT 2018


kristina added a comment.

Hi, I'll leave it in "Needs Review" state until there's some sort of clear consensus on the mailing lists, as far as I understand it you're backed by Debian CI infra, which means you at least have buildbots to ensure this back-end doesn't break or cause regressions in other parts of LLVM. I think as far as that part goes it is fine, but as Chandler explained, it's best to have an existing non-experimental back-end endorse you or getting some form of (even informal) downstream endorsement from Canonical or Debian that can be as simple as confirming you are able and have been maintaining this back-end downstream and that it has kept pace with the current development of LLVM. And as you mentioned yourself, that part is best left to the mailing lists. I would suggest discussing this over with at least one existing non-experimental backend owner at the very least regardless, you can find the list in `CODE_OWNERS.txt`. If there's some community interest and some form of endorsement (or heavy endorsement from one of the major downstream vendors), I'd be happy to re-review this. Leaving it open as I'll watch the lists and see how this goes and huge apologies for my hasty initial reply.


Repository:
  rL LLVM

https://reviews.llvm.org/D50858





More information about the llvm-commits mailing list