[Lldb-commits] [lldb] WIP: [lldb] Support Persistent Variables as DIL Identifiers (PR #215706)

Ilia Kuklin via lldb-commits lldb-commits at lists.llvm.org
Wed Aug 12 17:49:04 PDT 2026


kuilpd wrote:

> So the only advantage to making these persistent definitions (or result variables if you want them to be const) is if you wanted to have DIL results available to the expression evaluator. 

Or to use these results for subsequent DIL calls (as per this patch), same usage as in the expression evaluator.

> Otherwise you'd be paying the cost of sticking every DIL expression result in target memory and keeping them there forever since you really don't know when you could release them.

We could enable creating them only when used from the console, so that there won't be a lot of those variables generated from other calls. Same as when `expr` is used in the console.

> Now that the DIL can return new values (e.g. the result of "a + b") we need to make up containers for the results. The most obvious solution to that is ValueObjectConstResult. These expression results are pretty much always going to be const, so that seems the natural container.

> Both result variables and persistent definitions are wrappers around some kind of ValueObject that manage inserting them in memory, and also giving them a real location so that AddressOf works in the target.

DIL already does this, most of the time by using `ValueObject::CreateValueObjectFromScalar`. But they're not assigned any real address and operator `&` fails on those. I'm not sure if this is a problem, how important is that? They can still be used as values in other expressions.

> Also, you'd need to be careful to only do this for definitions, not references to extant things.

I have an idea how to persist only value objects created inside DIL.

All in all, other that the convenience of being able to reuse the results, I don't have any motivation to implement this, but at the same time I don't see much overhead in the implementation either. If the feature is not useful, then I won't look into it further.

https://github.com/llvm/llvm-project/pull/215706


More information about the lldb-commits mailing list