[llvm-commits] [LLVMdev] [PATCH] Add the disable_aslr option that will disable the address space layout randomization under AddressSanitizer on 10.6

[Alexander Potapenko]

> As for the patch, I really don't like
>   1. 3 different cases for 3 different flavors of MacOS. How are we goring
> to support it?
The first is Leopard, which we don't want to support at all. Maybe we
should check that in some other place.
The second is Snow Leopard, where ASLR is controlled by the
DYLD_NO_PIE env var, which is read by the dynamic loader.
The third is Lion, which does not support DYLD_NO_PIE, but instead
supports a flag I've mentioned above. I suppose further Mac OS
releases will support only this way.

There also is the MH_PIE bit in the Mach-O header, which we can flip
to disable ASLR. But I'm not sure whether it won't disable the PIE
behavior at all.
Also, we'll need some special tool for that.

>   2. doing setenv+reexec. This will be a debugging nightmare for us and for
> users.
One can avoid setenv+exec by setting disable_aslr to 0. In this case
we can print the big warning (if someone wants to run the binary under
GDB, ASLR will anyway be disabled).
>
> I would prefer just to print a descriptive warning message and exit:
>    ==123== ERROR: AddressSanitizer on MacOS requires to disable ASRL for the
> executable.
>    ==123== ERROR: You can do it this way:
>    ==123== ERROR: <how to disable ASLR>
>    ==123== ABORTING
"pass the no_pie to your linker"
We can do this in the Clang driver, but a proper fix will involve
removing all the instances of -pie from the arg list.
I've recently posted a question about that to cfe-dev, but
unfortunately nobody responded.

BTW, have you given up the idea of having zero offset for the shadow?
We'll need PIE for that.